Borussia Dortmund has parted ways with head coach Nuri Sahin following a string of disappointing results. The final straw was a 2-1 loss to Bologna in the Champions League, leaving last season’s finalists on the brink of elimination.
Sahin, who was appointed in June 2024 to succeed Edin Terzic, leaves with Dortmund languishing in 10th place in the Bundesliga and fighting for their European survival.
The Downfall: Key Reasons Behind Sahin’s Exit
1. Declining Domestic Form
Dortmund has started 2025 disastrously with three consecutive Bundesliga losses, leaving them seven points adrift of the top four. The lack of results at home severely dented the club’s aspirations of securing Champions League football next season.
2. Champions League Struggles
After last season’s Champions League final appearance, expectations were high. However, three group-stage defeats this term have left Dortmund in a precarious position, needing a victory over Shakhtar Donetsk and favorable results elsewhere to progress to the last 16.
3. Tactical Inconsistencies
Sahin was expected to instill a new identity of dominance and sophisticated possession football. Instead, the team often reverted to a basic, uninspired approach. Despite dominating possession in many matches, Dortmund struggled to break down compact defenses and create meaningful chances.
4. Defensive Frailties
Post-winter break, Dortmund’s aggressive attacking setup left them vulnerable to counter-attacks. This tactical imbalance was evident in their recent performances, including the defeat to Bologna, where they failed to control the game.
5. Weak Mental and Physical Preparation
Matthias Sammer, a club advisor, criticized the team for being both mentally and physically fragile. This lack of resilience has been a recurring theme in Dortmund’s campaign.
Sahin’s Statement and Club Reaction
Sahin admitted his failure to meet the club’s high expectations, saying:
“Unfortunately, we have not managed to live up to Borussia Dortmund’s sporting ambitions this season. I wish this special club all the best.”
Sporting director Lars Ricken added:
“We value Nuri Sahin and his work very much. This decision hurts me personally, but it was unavoidable after the game in Bologna.”
Expert Analysis: What Went Wrong?
German football expert Constantin Eckner highlighted several key issues:
- Inexperience: Sahin’s lack of managerial experience—limited to a stint at Antalyaspor—proved costly.
- Tactical Instability: The team lacked a clear identity, oscillating between possession-based football and a more pragmatic approach.
- Player Performance: With the exception of Jamie Gittens and Felix Nmecha, most players have underperformed this season.
What’s Next for Dortmund?
Managerial Change
Sahin’s successor will be Dortmund’s sixth manager since 2018, underlining the club’s struggles to find long-term stability. The new coach will need to address:
- Tactical clarity.
- Player development and motivation.
- Rebuilding confidence within the squad.
Squad Concerns
Beyond managerial issues, Dortmund faces a larger problem: an underperforming squad. The club’s reliance on a few standout players like Gittens and Nmecha exposes a lack of depth and consistency.
Dortmund’s Immediate Challenges
- Champions League Survival: A must-win game against Shakhtar Donetsk awaits.
- Bundesliga Recovery: Closing the gap to the top four is critical for financial and competitive reasons.
- Long-Term Stability: Identifying the right managerial fit is essential for sustained success.
