Ex-Arsenal winger believes Mikel Arteta would favour a move for Nico Williams over Kingsley Coman as transfer talk heats up
As Arsenal prepare for a pivotal summer in their evolution under Mikel Arteta, the conversation is already swirling around potential reinforcements. Chief among them? A new wide player — someone who can add pace, flair, and competition to an already dangerous frontline. And if you ask former Arsenal winger Jermaine Pennant, there’s one standout name that should be at the top of Arteta’s wishlist: Nico Williams.
Pennant, who knows a thing or two about operating down the flanks at the Emirates, offered his take on the ongoing Kingsley Coman vs. Nico Williams debate. While both are reportedly on Arsenal’s radar, it’s clear which direction Pennant believes the Gunners should go in — and which player Mikel Arteta would lean toward.
Why Jermaine Pennant backs Nico Williams for Arsenal
Speaking in an interview with Makthavare, Pennant didn’t hesitate when asked who would be the better fit for Arsenal. His answer was as pragmatic as it was insightful.
“I think Nico Williams would be more suited to the Premier League than Kingsley Coman,” he said. “I’d probably say he’s more of an attractive prospect to bring to the Emirates, especially given his age.”
At just 21, Williams has emerged as one of La Liga’s most exciting young talents. His electric pace, fearless dribbling, and growing maturity on the ball have turned heads not just in Spain, but across Europe. For a club like Arsenal — who are looking to build for the now and the future — Williams ticks a lot of boxes.
“You definitely wouldn’t turn your nose up at the opportunity to sign Coman,” Pennant added. “But I think out of the two, Mikel Arteta would favour a move to Williams.”
The case for Kingsley Coman: experience and pedigree
While Pennant clearly prefers Williams, he was quick to acknowledge what Kingsley Coman brings to the table — and it’s a lot. The French winger has won titles in every country he’s played in, and his silverware collection includes multiple Bundesliga crowns, Serie A success with Juventus, and a Champions League title.
“Something that Coman does offer that Williams doesn’t is experience in winning trophies,” Pennant noted. “He’s won a lot with Bayern Munich and that experience makes a real impact. It shows in the big moments, which Arsenal will want to be part of.”
That kind of experience, especially on the European stage, is not to be underestimated. Arsenal are trying to establish themselves as serious contenders, both domestically and in the Champions League. A player like Coman, who has been there and done it at the highest level, could be exactly what’s needed in high-pressure moments.
Youthful fearlessness vs. proven quality
But Pennant also highlighted a key trend in modern football: young players don’t fear the spotlight the way they once did. He pointed to Barcelona’s teenage prodigy Lamine Yamal as an example of that new wave of bold, unshackled talent.
“These youngsters nowadays fear nothing,” Pennant said. “Look at Lamine Yamal, he fears nothing and is really special.”
It’s a mindset that seems tailor-made for someone like Nico Williams — a player unafraid to take on defenders, express himself, and shoulder responsibility despite his age. Arsenal have shown a clear willingness to invest in this type of profile under Arteta, and Williams would fit seamlessly into that model.
Arsenal transfer strategy: balancing ambition and identity
This summer’s transfer window is shaping up to be a big one for the Gunners. After a season where they’ve challenged at the very top of the Premier League and made it deep into Europe, the next step is clear: strengthen and sustain.
Arteta’s desire to add another winger is well-documented. Bukayo Saka remains the undisputed starter on the right, but the lack of consistent depth behind him has been exposed at times. The addition of a dynamic, high-level wide man could give Arsenal a whole new dimension — especially if they aim to compete on all fronts next season.
That’s why players like Coman and Williams are being considered. Both bring pace, technical skill, and tactical versatility. Both can operate on either wing. And both, in their own way, could elevate the team.
But with Williams reportedly available for a release clause of £50 million (€60m), and at an age where his best years are still to come, it’s no surprise that the links are growing stronger. According to reports, Arsenal have already opened talks with the 21-year-old’s representatives. They’re also believed to have explored the possibility of signing Coman, initiating discussions with the Bayern Munich winger’s entourage earlier this month.
What’s next for Arteta’s Gunners?
While the transfer rumours swirl, Arsenal’s focus remains firmly on the pitch. Next up? A blockbuster Champions League semi-final clash against Paris Saint-Germain on Tuesday, April 29.
It’s exactly the kind of occasion that underlines the importance of squad depth and game-changing quality off the bench — the very qualities that signings like Williams or Coman would bring.
With the stakes rising and the margins getting smaller, Arsenal know they need more firepower to push on. And with a young, ambitious manager in Arteta and a clear recruitment philosophy, they’re well-positioned to make the right moves.
Jermaine Pennant’s advice won’t be the only voice Arteta hears this summer — but it’s a voice that carries a certain weight, especially among those who know what it means to wear the shirt.
One thing’s certain: whether it’s Kingsley Coman or Nico Williams, Arsenal are setting their sights high. And that alone should be enough to excite the fans heading into a summer of promise.
